Skip to content
Gideon Advert
Shopify

Shopify vs a Custom Website: Which Is Right for Your Business?

The right choice depends on what you sell and who will run the site. Here is a plain comparison, including when neither is the answer.

By Gideon Advert · · 5 min read · Last updated

"Should I use Shopify or build a custom website?" is one of the most common questions from anyone starting to sell online. It is also one that gets bad answers, because the people answering usually sell one of the two options.

This guide sets out what each approach is good at, where each one costs more than people expect, and how to choose. It also covers a third answer that is easy to miss: sometimes you do not need an online shop at all.

First, define what you are comparing

Shopify is a hosted platform for running an online store. It provides the cart, checkout, order management, payment connections and a catalogue system. You choose a theme, add products and configure settings. Shopify handles the technology underneath.

A custom website is built specifically for you, usually by a developer, using code or a content management system. It can include a shop, but then the shop's cart, checkout, payments, security and order handling are either built, connected to third-party services or handled by a plugin you must keep up to date.

What Shopify does well

  • Selling is built in. Cart, checkout, discount codes, inventory and order management work from the start.
  • Hosting and platform security are handled by Shopify, so you are not maintaining servers.
  • Speed to launch. A tidy store can be live much sooner than a custom build.
  • A large ecosystem of themes and apps for common needs.
  • Day-to-day management is designed for business owners, not developers.

Where Shopify costs more or limits you

  • Platform fees. You pay Shopify a plan fee, and payment processing has its own fees. Check Shopify's current pages, because they change.
  • Apps add up. Each app can add its own monthly fee, and too many slow a store down and complicate it.
  • Design and logic have limits. Unusual product options, custom pricing rules or very specific page layouts may need developer work or may not be possible within the platform.
  • You depend on a platform whose terms and prices you do not control.

What a custom website does well

  • Total control over design, structure and behaviour.
  • The freedom to build something a platform cannot do, such as unusual booking, quoting or account features.
  • Fewer recurring platform fees, depending on how it is built.
  • A site that can be exactly as simple, or as unusual, as your business needs.

Where a custom website costs more than people expect

  • Upfront cost. A custom build takes more design and development time.
  • Ongoing care. Hosting, updates, backups, security and fixes are your responsibility, or a care plan's.
  • Payments. Taking card payments safely means integrating a payment provider and handling the details correctly.
  • Change requests. Updating something structural may mean paying a developer again.

A quick comparison by situation

  • You sell physical products and want to start soon: Shopify is usually the straightforward choice.
  • You sell a handful of products or digital items and want to test demand: start with a simple store on a free or low-cost theme, and invest in design later.
  • You have a large or unusual catalogue with custom pricing or options: either a heavily extended Shopify store or a custom build, and you should ask for a written scope for each before deciding.
  • You sell services, such as consulting, repairs or appointments: you probably need a business website with an enquiry or booking route, not a shop.
  • You need accounts, quoting logic or integrations that no shop platform supports: a custom build may be the honest answer.

The third option: you may not need a shop yet

A common and costly mistake is paying for a shop when the business actually sells a service. If customers need to talk to you before they buy, a clear website with a quote form does the job and is simpler to run. You can add a shop later if you start selling products.

Questions to ask yourself

  • How many products will I sell in the first year, and how often will they change?
  • Do I need anything a normal cart cannot do, such as quote-based pricing or custom product builders?
  • Who will manage the site every week, and how technical are they?
  • What will it cost per month once it is live, including platform, apps, payments and hosting?
  • How soon do I need it live?

How we approach it

If the answer is Shopify, our Shopify Basic Store Setup starts at $80 as a one-time fee. It includes adding products to your store and a basic homepage store design with 4 sections. Shopify's own plan, themes, apps and payment fees are billed by those providers. Custom theme work, Liquid development, apps, migrations, large catalogues, extra pages or sections and other custom work are quoted separately after a brief, because the effort varies too much to price in advance.

If the answer is a website, our website packages start at $300 one-time. We would rather tell you which one you need than sell you the one with the bigger fee.

Whichever way you go, write the answers to the questions above on one page first. They will make every conversation with every provider faster, cheaper and more honest.

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a short brief and we will reply by email with what we would do first, and what it costs.