Skip to content
Gideon Advert
Meta Ads

How to Compare Facebook Ads Management Agencies Side by Side

Two Facebook ads proposals rarely look alike. Here is a simple scorecard for comparing agencies fairly, and what to look for in each quote.

By Gideon Advert · · 5 min read · Last updated

Once you have two or three proposals from Facebook ads management agencies, the hard part begins: they rarely look alike. One lists tools, another lists deliverables and a third lists a price with very little else. Comparing them fairly takes a method.

This guide gives you a simple scorecard to compare Facebook ads management agencies side by side, explains what to look for in each proposal and shows how to judge two quotes that are priced differently. If you are still choosing who to ask, start with the guide linked below, then come back here to compare.

Why is comparing agency proposals so difficult?

Agencies describe the same work in different words and bundle it differently, so the totals are not like for like. A fair comparison needs the same questions answered for every agency, in writing, in a form you can lay next to each other.

The fix is to turn every proposal into the same short list of facts before you look at the price.

What does a simple comparison scorecard look like?

Score each agency from one to five on the points below, and write one line of evidence for each score. The evidence matters more than the number.

  • Goal and offer: did they agree one clear goal with you, such as quote requests or bookings, and describe how it will be measured?
  • Scope in writing: is what they manage listed, including what is excluded?
  • Landing page: do they review the page the ads will send people to, and tell you what to change?
  • Ownership: will the ad account, Pixel and audiences belong to your business?
  • Reporting: does the report show enquiries or sales and what happens next, not only impressions and reach?
  • Fees: are the management fee, ad spend and any other costs separate and clear?
  • Contract: is the billing period short and the way to stop simple?

Add the scores and keep the notes. A single point of concern, such as no clear ownership of the account, can outweigh a high total.

How do you compare two quotes with different prices?

Compare what each fee covers, not the headline number. A lower price can mean less included, and a higher price can include things the other agency leaves out or charges for later.

  • List every task each quote includes, such as setup, copy, creative direction, audience management and reporting.
  • Note what is excluded, for example landing page changes, extra creative or a second ad account.
  • Check whether ad spend is paid directly to Meta, and whether the agency adds a percentage.
  • Ask what happens in month two if results are weak, and who pays for changes.

Our Marketing and Ads Management plan is $199 per month for campaign setup, copy and creative direction, audience and budget management, landing page recommendations and reporting, with ad spend paid separately to Meta. The point of listing it is that every line is visible, which is how any agency's quote should look.

What should you look for in each proposal?

Read each proposal for specifics. Detail is a good sign, and vague promises are a warning.

Does the proposal mention your business?

A proposal that uses your offer, customers and website shows the agency listened. A copy-and-paste proposal that could apply to anyone usually means a generic plan.

Does it explain how the campaign will be tested?

Look for a plan such as testing one message or audience against another, with a reason for each choice, instead of a list of features.

Does it promise outcomes?

Be cautious of guaranteed leads, sales or return on spend. Results depend on your offer, page, market and competition, which no agency controls.

Is the reporting described?

Ask to see a sample report. You want to see what the campaign produced and what the agency would change next.

How do you test an agency before you commit?

Ask the same practical questions of every agency and compare the answers, then consider a short, low-risk start. A shorter commitment lets you see how they work before you commit to more.

  • Ask each agency to explain, in a few sentences, what they would do first with your budget and why.
  • Ask who will work on your account and how often you will speak to them.
  • Ask how they would handle a campaign that is not working after the first few weeks.
  • Ask for the contract terms in writing and read the cancellation clause.

How should you make the final decision?

Choose the agency whose answers were clearest, whose scope and fees were written down and who treated your page and offer as part of the job. That agency is usually the safest choice even when it is not the cheapest.

If two agencies score the same, pick the one that gave you the most useful advice before you paid anything.

How does Gideon Advert approach Meta Ads?

We plan the campaign and the page behind it together, and we ask for your offer, goal and landing page before building anything. You see the scope in writing before work starts, and we report in plain English.

Frequently asked questions

How many Facebook ads agencies should I compare?

Two or three is enough. Give each the same short brief so the proposals are easy to compare.

Should I pick the cheapest agency?

Not by default. Compare what each fee includes and how clearly the scope and reporting are described.

What should a Facebook ads proposal include?

The goal, the scope with inclusions and exclusions, who owns the accounts, how reporting works, the fees and the contract terms.

Can I switch agencies later?

Yes, if you own the ad account and its data. That is why ownership is one of the first things to check.

Do I need a landing page before running Facebook ads?

You need a page that explains the offer and makes the next step easy, whether that is a full website or a single landing page.

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a short brief and we will reply by email with what we would do first, and what it costs.