Shopify Developer vs DIY Shopify Store Builder: Which Should You Choose?
Doing it yourself and hiring a developer both work on Shopify. Here is what each involves, where each fits, and how to decide.
By Gideon Advert · · 6 min read · Last updated
Shopify is built so that an ordinary business owner can open a store without writing code. That is real, and it makes the choice between building it yourself and hiring a developer a fair question rather than an obvious one.
This guide is about that choice: who builds the store once you have decided to use Shopify. If you are still deciding between Shopify and a different kind of site, start with our guide to Shopify versus a custom website. We sell Shopify setup, so we have an interest here, and we try to say plainly where doing it yourself is the better answer.
What does building a Shopify store yourself involve?
Doing it yourself means you choose a theme, set up your branding, add every product with its photos and description, build the menus and policy pages, and configure payment, shipping and tax settings. Shopify's own tools guide you through most of it. The main cost is your time and attention rather than money.
- Choosing and configuring a theme.
- Adding products, variants, photos and descriptions.
- Building navigation, collections and policy pages.
- Setting up payments, shipping rates and tax.
- Testing the store on phone and computer before launch.
What does a Shopify developer add?
A developer brings experience of what makes a store clear and trustworthy, and can do work that goes beyond the standard settings: custom design, theme code changes, app set-up, migrations and speed clean-up. They also save you time. What you pay for is largely the hours you do not spend learning, and the mistakes you avoid.
When is doing it yourself the right choice?
DIY is a sensible choice when the store is simple and you have the time. It tends to fit if most of these are true.
- You have a small number of products.
- A well-designed standard theme is good enough for now.
- You enjoy learning tools and have the hours to spare.
- You are not moving data from another platform.
- Your budget for the first version is very small.
When does hiring a Shopify developer make sense?
Hiring makes sense when your time is worth more than the fee, or when the job is beyond the standard settings. It tends to fit if any of these apply.
- You are moving products and customers from another platform.
- You want a design built for your brand, not a configured theme.
- You need extra functionality that requires apps or code.
- Your store already exists and feels slow, messy or hard to use.
- You have a launch date and not enough hours to meet it.
- You have a large catalogue to add.
What does each route really cost?
Both routes pay the same platform costs: Shopify's plan, any paid theme, apps and payment processing fees are billed by those providers however the store is built. The difference is what you pay for the build. DIY costs your hours. A developer costs a fee and saves most of those hours.
At Gideon Advert, Shopify Basic Store Setup starts at $80 one-time and includes adding products to your store and a basic homepage store design with 4 sections. Custom design, apps, migrations, large catalogues and extra pages or sections are quoted separately from a brief. That is a published starting price, not a promise that every store costs that much.
What mistakes do DIY stores commonly make?
Most are not technical. They come from not having seen many stores go wrong. Watch for these on your own store.
- Product pages with one photo and a thin description.
- Shipping and returns information that is hard to find.
- Too many apps installed, each adding weight and cost.
- Menus built around internal names, not the words customers use.
- A store never tested on a real phone, from product page to payment.
- Missing or copied policy pages.
Is there a middle route?
Yes, and it is a common one. You can pay for the foundation and handle the day-to-day yourself: a developer sets up the foundation, and you add or update products afterwards. Shopify's admin is designed for owners to manage, so many people do exactly this. Another version is to build it yourself and pay for a review, such as our free website audit, before you launch.
What should I hand to a developer even if I do the rest?
If you build most of the store yourself, a few jobs are worth handing over because they are easy to get wrong and hard to undo. The rest you can usually keep.
- Hand over: moving data from another platform, changes to theme code, speed clean-up and any custom functionality.
- Hand over: a final review before launch, with fresh eyes on the product pages and the phone experience.
- Keep: day-to-day product changes, prices, stock and promotions.
- Keep: your photos, descriptions and the voice of the store, which only you know well.
How do I decide?
Ask yourself these six questions and be honest about the answers.
- How many hours can I realistically give this before launch?
- How custom does the design need to be?
- Am I moving data from another platform?
- Do I need anything beyond a standard theme and standard settings?
- What does a month of delay cost me?
- Would I rather learn the tools or run the business?
If the answers point to a simple store and plenty of time, start yourself. If they point to custom work, a migration or a tight date, hire. If they are mixed, take the middle route.
Frequently asked questions
Can I start myself and hire a developer later?
Yes. Many owners do. Keep a note of what feels slow or unclear as you go, and bring that list to a developer when you are ready for help.
Will a developer make my store sell more?
We cannot promise that, and no honest developer can. A good one removes friction and makes the store clearer. Sales also depend on traffic, price, product and brand.
Do I keep control of my store if I hire someone?
You should. Agree in writing whose account the store sits in, who holds the logins and what happens at the end of the project, before work starts.
Is Shopify the right platform for me at all?
If you sell products online, often. If you mainly offer a service and collect enquiries, a business website may suit you better. Our Shopify versus custom website guide explains the trade-offs.