Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Digital Marketing Agency
The right questions show quickly whether an agency is clear and honest. Here are the ones to ask before you hire a digital marketing agency.
By Gideon Advert · · 6 min read · Last updated
Most agencies look good in a sales call, so the questions you ask matter more than the pitch you hear. A few plain questions will show whether an agency has a real plan for your business or a package it sells to everyone.
This guide lists the questions to ask before you hire a digital marketing agency, explains what a good answer sounds like and points out the answers that should make you pause. It works for any agency or freelancer, including us.
Why do the questions you ask matter so much?
Hiring a digital marketing agency means paying for work you cannot easily check, so you rely on how clearly the agency explains itself. Specific answers are a good sign, and vague ones usually mean there is not much behind them.
Write the questions down before the call and ask every agency the same ones. That makes the replies easy to compare afterwards.
What should you ask about your goals?
What will you aim for, and how will we know it worked?
A good agency agrees one clear goal with you first, such as quote requests, bookings or online sales, and says how it will be measured. Be careful with answers that talk about traffic, followers or "brand awareness" without connecting them to something your business needs.
What do you need to know about my business before you start?
A careful agency asks about your offer, customers, margins and website before it recommends anything. If it proposes a plan on the first call without asking, the plan is probably generic.
What should you ask about the work itself?
Who will actually do the work?
Ask who writes, designs, builds and manages your campaigns, and whether it is the same people you speak to now. There is nothing wrong with a team or a specialist, but you should know who is responsible for each part.
Which services do you offer, and which do you not?
An honest agency says what it does not do. Be wary of an agency that claims to do everything equally well, from websites to ads to SEO to video.
How do the website, search and ads fit together?
The pieces should be planned together. An ad is only as good as the page it sends people to, and a good page still needs visitors.
What should you ask about ownership and access?
Who owns the accounts, the website and the data?
Your business should own its website, domain, ad accounts, analytics and customer data, with the agency given access. If everything sits in the agency's name, you can lose it when you stop working together.
Will I see what you are doing?
You should have read access to the ad account, analytics and anything else paid for with your money. Work done behind a curtain makes it hard to judge value.
What should you ask about reporting?
What will the report show, and how often?
The report should show what the work produced, such as enquiries or sales, what changed since last time and what happens next. A report that lists only impressions, reach or rankings does not tell you whether you are getting value.
What happens if results are weak?
A good agency explains how it will find the cause, for example the offer, the page or the audience, and what it would change. Be cautious of anyone who has no answer or blames you.
What should you ask about fees and contracts?
What exactly do I pay, and what is not included?
Ask for the monthly fee, any setup fee and anything paid to other companies, such as ad spend, software or domains. The written scope should list inclusions and exclusions.
How long is the contract, and how do I leave?
Look for a clear billing period and a simple way to cancel. A long lock-in with no written scope puts all the risk on you.
Which answers should make you walk away?
Some answers are warning signs, whatever the agency's size or reputation.
- Guaranteed rankings, leads, sales or return on spend. Results depend on your market, offer, website and competition, which no agency controls.
- Refusing to give you ownership of your accounts or data.
- No written scope, or a scope that avoids saying what is excluded.
- Reports that avoid results.
- Pressure to sign quickly or spend more without a clear reason.
- A plan that is identical for every business.
How can you compare agencies once you have the answers?
Put the replies side by side and score them on clarity, not on who sounds most confident. The agency that is specific about goals, ownership, fees and reporting is usually the safer choice, even if it is not the cheapest.
- Did they ask about your business before proposing anything?
- Is the scope written down, including what is excluded?
- Do you own your accounts and data?
- Are fees, billing period and cancellation terms clear?
- Will the report show results, not just activity?
How does Gideon Advert answer these questions?
We publish our prices and list what each package includes and what it does not, so you can check them before you pay. Our website packages start at $300 for the Starter Website, with the Growth Website at $600 and the Growth Pro Website at $1,500, and our monthly plans start at $79. We confirm the scope in writing before work starts, and we do not guarantee rankings, leads or sales.
If you want to talk it through, send a short brief and we will reply with what we would do and what it would cost.
Frequently asked questions
How many agencies should I speak to?
Two or three is enough. Give each the same short brief so the answers are easy to compare.
Should I hire a freelancer or an agency?
Either can work. What matters is a clear scope, ownership of your accounts and honest reporting, not the size of the business.
How much should a digital marketing agency cost?
It varies with the work. Focus on what the fee covers, what is paid separately and whether the scope is written down, rather than on the lowest price.
What should I prepare before contacting an agency?
Know your goal, what you sell, who you want to reach, your budget range and the pages or accounts you already have.
Can an agency guarantee results?
No. An agency controls its own work, not your market or competitors, so any guarantee is a warning sign.