How to Choose a Web Design Agency: 9 Questions to Ask First
Most agencies look alike on their homepages. These nine questions show you the differences that matter before you commit.
By Gideon Advert · · 6 min read · Last updated
Choosing a web design agency is harder than it should be. Every agency says it is creative, professional and results-driven, every portfolio looks polished, and every quote arrives in a different format. If you are comparing three of them, you are probably comparing three different things without realising it.
This guide gives you a way to compare them properly: what to decide before you start, how to read a portfolio, what a good proposal contains, the red flags worth walking away from, and nine questions that quickly separate a careful agency from a careless one.
Start with the job, not the agency
Before you contact anyone, write down what the website needs to do. Not "look modern", but a job a visitor can complete: request a quote, book an appointment, buy a product, or phone you. A website with one clear job is easier to design, easier to price and easier to judge afterwards.
- Who is the visitor, and what are they trying to find out?
- What is the one action you want them to take?
- What do they doubt before they take it, such as price, timing or trust?
- Which pages must exist, and which can wait?
- Who will keep the site up to date after launch?
An agency that asks you these questions before quoting is already ahead of one that sends a price after a single email.
How to read a portfolio
A portfolio proves that an agency can produce attractive pages. It does not, on its own, prove that the sites work for the businesses that own them. Ask yourself what you can actually conclude.
- Open the live sites if they are live. Check them on your phone. Do they load comfortably, and is the contact route obvious?
- Look for variety of problem, not just variety of colour. Has the agency built a booking site, a shop and a service site, or the same template three times?
- Ask what the agency did on each project. Design only, or structure, copy, forms and SEO setup too?
- Be careful with big claims. If a portfolio shows results, ask how they were measured and who measured them. If it shows none, that is not automatically bad, but it means you must judge on process.
What a good proposal contains
The most useful thing a proposal can do is let you compare. A good one lists, in plain language, what you are paying for and what you are not.
- The number of pages and what each is for.
- The features included, such as forms, booking links, analytics or tracking.
- The number of revision rounds, and what happens if you need more.
- What is excluded, for example photography, logo design or long-form copywriting.
- What is billed by other companies: your domain name, hosting, booking software, email platforms.
- What you must supply, and how late content affects the timeline.
- Whether any fee repeats monthly, and how to cancel it.
If one quote is $400 and another is $4,000, check whether they cover the same pages, features and revisions before assuming one is a bargain and the other a rip-off. Often they are not quoting the same job.
Nine questions to ask before you sign
- What exactly is included, page by page and feature by feature?
- How many rounds of changes are included, and what do extra rounds cost?
- Who will actually do the work, and who will I talk to?
- What will I need to provide, and what happens to the timeline if it arrives late?
- What do I pay after launch, and which of those costs are optional?
- Who owns the website, the design files and the content once it is finished?
- Where will it be hosted, and who controls the domain name and the logins?
- How will the site be set up for search, and what do you promise about rankings?
- What happens if we disagree, or if I want to move to another provider later?
Listen to how they answer, not only to what they say. Clear, specific answers in writing are a good sign. Vague answers, or a reluctance to put things in writing, are not.
Red flags worth walking away from
- Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed leads. Nobody controls search results or customer decisions, so a guarantee is either a lie or a very narrow promise dressed up as a big one.
- A price with no scope. If they cannot say what the price covers, you cannot compare it with anything.
- Pressure to decide today, or a discount that expires tonight.
- No mention of ongoing costs. Hosting, updates and domains cost money whoever builds the site.
- Unclear ownership. You should know whether you own your domain, your content and the finished site.
- Reviews that cannot be traced to real people, or case studies with no named business and no explanation.
Agency, freelancer, or do-it-yourself builder?
None of these is always right. A freelancer can be a good fit for a small, clearly defined job, and a single point of contact is a real advantage. The trade-off is that one person has limited time and a limited range of skills, and if they become unavailable you may have to start again.
A small agency usually offers more range, such as design, development, search and advertising under one roof, which helps when those pieces need to fit together. The risk is that "agency" tells you very little. Ask who does the work.
A do-it-yourself builder costs the least in money and the most in time. It suits simple sites and owners who enjoy the work. It is a poor choice if you have no time or if the site needs to do something more specific than the template allows.
How we answer these questions
It would be unfair to give you this list and dodge it ourselves, so here are the short versions of our answers. Our website design prices are published and one-time: $300 for Starter (up to 5 pages), $600 for Growth (up to 8 pages) and $1,500 for Growth Pro (up to 12 pages). Every package states its pages, features and revision rounds, and the scope is agreed in writing before work starts. Hosting, domains and third-party tools are billed separately, and our optional Website Care & Hosting plan is $79/month.
We do not guarantee rankings or leads. Our case studies show what we built and the search data behind two live stores, and client reviews from our Upwork profile are on our homepage, quoted word for word. What you can check today is our case studies, our past work, the published prices and the written scope you receive before any work begins.
A simple way to decide
Shortlist two or three providers. Send each the same short brief. Compare the answers to the nine questions above, the clarity of the scope and the way they communicate while you are still only a prospect. How an agency behaves before you pay is usually the best preview of how it behaves afterwards.