Skip to content
Gideon Advert
SEO

How to Choose the Best SEO Agency for Your Business

There is no single best SEO agency, only the right fit. Here is how to compare agencies, what to ask and which promises to avoid.

By Gideon Advert · · 5 min read · Last updated

Search for the best SEO agency and you will meet bold promises, rankings lists and reviews that are hard to check. Hiring the wrong one can cost months, and nobody can fix that after the fact.

This guide explains what an SEO agency actually does, what to decide before you contact one, how to judge their work and which promises should worry you. It applies to any agency or freelancer, including us.

What does an SEO agency actually do?

An SEO agency works to help the right people find your website through search engines such as Google. Most of the work is practical and unglamorous: fixing site problems, improving pages, creating useful content and tracking what changes.

  • Technical fixes: making the site fast, crawlable and easy for search engines to understand.
  • On-page work: titles, descriptions, headings and page content that match what people search for.
  • Content: pages and articles that answer real customer questions.
  • Local presence: Google Business Profile guidance for businesses that serve a local area.
  • Tracking and reporting: showing what changed and what the numbers mean.

Is there a single best SEO agency?

No. The best agency is the one that fits your goals, budget and market, and explains what it does in plain language. A large agency may suit a company with a big budget, while a small business may do better with a focused, clearly priced service.

What should you decide before you contact an SEO agency?

  • What do you want from search: phone calls, quote requests, online sales or bookings?
  • Who are your customers, and what would they type into Google?
  • Is your website ready? Search work on a broken or slow site wastes money.
  • What is your monthly budget, and how long can you commit?
  • Who will approve changes on your side?

How do you tell a good SEO agency from a bad one?

A good agency is specific. It tells you what it will change, why, and how you will know. A bad one hides behind jargon, guarantees and vague reports.

  • They explain their work in plain language you can repeat to someone else.
  • They ask about your business, customers and goals before proposing anything.
  • They show what is included and what is not, in writing.
  • They are honest that results take time and cannot be guaranteed.
  • They give you access to your own accounts, such as Search Console and analytics.

What questions should you ask an SEO agency?

  • What exactly will you do each month, and what will I receive?
  • Who owns the website, the content and the analytics accounts?
  • How will you measure progress, and what will you report?
  • What will you need from me, and by when?
  • What happens if I want to stop? Is there a minimum contract?
  • Can you show real work I can check, and explain what you personally did?
  • Which of your recommendations might I be able to do myself?

How long does SEO take to show results?

Usually months, not days. Search engines need time to find, assess and trust changes, and competition varies a lot. An agency that promises quick top rankings is selling certainty it cannot have.

What should an SEO report contain?

A useful report is short and readable. It shows what changed, what the numbers did, and what happens next.

  • What was done this month, in plain words.
  • How impressions, clicks and enquiries changed, from Search Console and analytics.
  • Which pages are growing, and which need work.
  • What comes next, and anything you need to approve.

Be wary of reports that are mostly charts, keyword lists or a single rankings number with no explanation.

What are the warning signs when hiring an SEO agency?

  • They guarantee rankings, a number one spot or a fixed amount of traffic.
  • They will not tell you what they do, or call it a secret method.
  • They offer to buy links for you or use automated link building.
  • They ask for ownership of your website, domain or accounts.
  • They cannot show work you can verify yourself.
  • The price and scope are vague, or they push a long contract with no exit.

Should you hire an SEO agency or a freelancer?

Either can work. A freelancer is often more direct and affordable, while an agency may offer more people and process. What matters is clear scope, honest reporting and access to your own accounts.

How does Gideon Advert approach SEO?

Our SEO Growth plan is $149 a month. It includes on-page improvements, Search Console and analytics monitoring, content recommendations, Google Business Profile guidance and a monthly summary. We do not guarantee rankings, and we tell you what we changed and what we would do next.

Frequently asked questions

How much does an SEO agency cost?

It varies widely with scope and competition. Ask for a written quote that lists what is included and excluded. Our published SEO Growth plan is $149 a month.

Can an SEO agency guarantee first-page rankings?

No. Search engines decide rankings, and nobody controls them. Treat any guarantee as a warning sign.

Do I need a new website before I hire an SEO agency?

Not always. A site that loads quickly, works on phones and clearly explains what you do can be improved. A broken or very slow site usually needs fixing first.

What should I do myself before hiring an agency?

Make sure your business details are correct on your site, claim your Google Business Profile if you qualify, and set up Search Console so you can see what is happening.

Who should own the SEO accounts?

You should. Your Search Console, analytics and website accounts should stay in your name, with the agency given access.

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a short brief and we will reply by email with what we would do first, and what it costs.